In last night's Thursday Night matchup between the Bears and the Patriots, head coach Ben Johnson drew up and called what might be the weirdest trick play any of us will see in the 2026 NFL season. It's also a thoroughly illegal play.
The play in question happened with 7:50 to go in the 2nd quarter. On a 2nd & 3, Caleb Williams takes the ball from under center, fakes a handoff to De'Andre Swift on an End Around motion, and simultaneously uses his other hand to hand the ball off to Joe Thuney who is pretending to pull. Thuney cradles the ball for a second while the defense pursues Swift, before he spins around and runs up field for 2 yards before being tackled.
The announcer, Al Michaels, immediately calls it a "beautiful" trick play, until the penalty flag comes out, and the referees bring it back 5 yards and lose the down on an "Illegal Forward Handoff" penalty call. Even the referee appears to stumble when signaling and calling the penalty, because I'm sure he has never had to call this particular penalty in his life. It's a penalty that probably hasn't been called in the NFL for a hundred years -- if ever!
The Bears run an illegal handoff to pulling Guard Joe Thuney.
Watching the play, it appears that Joe Thuney and Caleb Williams run this play as it was designed and practiced. Thuney does not attempt to pull deeper than Williams, and Williams does not seem to make any attempt to make the handoff a lateral or backwards handoff (which would have made the play legal). So did Coach Johnson put this play in the gameplan and call it, knowing that it is illegal, and just hoping that the refs wouldn't call it? Or did they install this play, and nobody on the Bears' coaching staff knew that it was blatantly against the rules?
Friends and co-workers suggested to me that maybe the coaches used A.I. to come up with the design of the play, but I think this is highly unlikely. They also suggested that Johnson was simply testing the referees to see if they would catch and call this obvious, but rarely (if ever) enforced penalty. If so, then it's very risky to call something like this in that game situation -- up by only 3 in the 2nd quarter. If you were up by, like, 3 scores, or it was the preseason, and you just want to run something silly or experimental to test the refs and the NFL's rules, then that's one thing. Bill Belicheck has been known to do stuff like that, especially in preseason.
Also, I want to point out that De'Andre Swift does a horrible job of selling the End Around. He doesn't pretend to be holding the football at all, so the defense immediately reacts to the fake and turns to pursue Williams and/or Thuney. Also, it's possible that Swift ran his End Around motion too deep, which might be why Williams has to stretch so far for the play fake, and why Thuney ends up in front of Williams. Maybe if Swift had run the Jet motion more shallow, Williams would be able to hand the ball laterally to Thuney, and the play would be legal. Maybe the Bears will try running this again in the future, but with a better fake action. So in the future, Coach Johnson, if you're going to run a trick fake, maybe fake the ball to somebody else who's actually going to put some effort into forcing the defense to bite.
© Amazon Prime, NFL.
Joe Thuney and Caleb Williams appear to execute the play as it was designed and practiced, which is illegal.
Legal or not, this is exactly the kind of wild play that we all expected when the Bears hired Johnson. It's also exactly the kind of play that really makes players buy into what a coach is selling. Johnson is trying to do things that the rest of the NFL isn't doing, and he's trying to get everyone involved in it. Designing plays to get touches to offensive lineman will stir up excitement and enthusiasm in the locker room.
I hope to see more of it!