Madden NFL 27 - title

If you already read my review of College Football 27, then you know that I was late getting into the mood for football season due to delays in migrating my NFL fantasy football league to the ESPN service. I didn't even start looking to buy a used copy of Madden 27 until a week or 2 into September. I didn't even get around to meaningfully playing Madden until October.

If you read my review of College Football 27, then you also already know that my first impressions of that game were surprisingly positive. The game appeared to have features that I'd wanted for years, and overall seemed (initially) to be a much more polished experience than what I was used to from EA Sports. Madden 27 gave me almost the exact opposite initial impression. Before I'd even gotten to the main menu, Madden 27 was already prompting me to pay money to buy some kind of season pass. That's right, the game was begging me for more money before I had even properly started it!

I don't even bother playing or reviewing Ultimate Team anymore. It's pay-to-win garbage that keeps getting more and more expensive every year.

EA was begging me for more money before I had even loaded into the Main Menu!

Once I skipped past that bullshit, I was immediately bombarded by more technical incompetence and bugs. The title screen featured a cool remix of Madden's soundtrack, and I wanted to see what other music was available. But when I tried demoing the other tracks, the title screen theme continued to play over them, and it was obnoxiously loud.

I could not get the title theme to stop playing. I tried disabling the song in the music menu, I tried going into Settings to change the volume, I tried changing the audio presets, but nothing would work. The menu assaulted my ears with 2 or 3 songs playing on top of each, and I couldn't get them to stop! My only recourse was to quit the game entirely, after which the music worked properly, and I could correctly demo the other tracks in the game. (It's a much more varied and appealing soundtrack than usual, featuring a lot more rock, classic rock, and even some country tracks to go along with the hip hop and rap tracks that I mostly had to disable.)

On top of this, Madden suffered from the same initial problem that College Football 27 suffered from, which was that the tutorial for the new timed catching mechanic simply didn't work. The game prompts the player to choose your preference for settings for things like passing mode, kicking meter, and catching, and also gives you the option to test each method right there from the setting menu. But, since timed catching was disabled by default, when I pressed "Try" for the timed catching demo tutorial, the timed catching mechanic was not temporarily enabled for the tutorial, and so the timed catching mechanic didn't work. Since I had already played College Football 27, I immediately recognized the problem, didn't have to go to the internet to figure out what I was doing wrong, and was able to go straight to the settings to turn the feature on.

The timed catch meter overlaps the pass meter,
making the catch meter difficult to read.

Once I enabled timed catching and re-tried the tutorial, I found the mechanic to be even more difficult to use than it was in College Football 27 (if you can believe that!). The problem was that the passing meter was overlapping and obstructing the catch meter, making it even harder to see the movement of the timing indicator along the meter.

Thus, my initial impressions of Madden 27 was that it was a visual and auditory mess -- a cacophony of sound and unreadable U.I. -- and full of technical incompetence. Yeah, sure, many of the same features and options that initially impressed me with College Football 27 are here too. The Coaching Adjustments menu, Custom Adjustments, and so forth are in Madden 27 as well. But these didn't initially impress me the way they did with College Football 27 because I had already played with them in College Football 27, and was also already well aware of their shortcomings and limitations.

In contrast to College Football, Madden does include the new Coaching Adjustment settings in the Franchise settings menu, so I don't have to exit Franchise entirely to change my adjustment settings. That's good. But these settings aren't saved with the rest of the Franchise settings; so changes made in Franchise apply to other game modes as well, and vice-versa. And unlike gameplay sliders, I can't save and load Coaching Adjustment pre-sets. This means that if I want to keep Coaching Adjustments specifically for Franchise play, and have different (or default) settings for Play Now and online play, I have to change these settings every time I switch game modes. Heck, there isn't even a "Restore Defaults" command. So just like with College Football, this feature feels like a bust.

Custom Adjustments, on the other hand, are not available in Franchise at all. Just like in College Football 27, I have to exit Franchise entirely if I want to add or change Custom Adjustments. And since there's no way to accurately scout an opponent's play-calling in Franchise (or CFB's Dynasty) and then practice against their plays, I never use the Custom Adjustments because I don't know what Custom Adjustments are good to use or when would be a good time to use them.

Coaching Adjustment settings are available within the Franchise settings menu, but are still globally applied.

If Madden 27 was going to impress me, it was going to have to do it in other ways...

[More]

Tags:, , , , , , , , , ,

EA Sports College Football 27 - title

I really was not ready for the start of football season this year. Part of that is the fault of NFL Fantasy Football, which migrated its leagues to ESPN's fantasy app, but waited till the 11th hour to actually enable the ability to transfer. I got the email about it in the spring, and was just kind of waiting to get further instructions from the NFL on how to do the migration. Those instructions didn't come until like the end of July, only a couple weeks before the start of the NFL preseason.

This delay in setting up my fantasy football leagues this year meant I wasn't really thinking about football, and didn't even bother looking for cheap copies of College Football 27 on eBay when the game released. I ended up buying my used copy off eBay a whole month after the game's release. In fact, it was so late, that I received the game in the mail the day before Madden 27's official release. So I'll probably be late about getting my pre-owned copy of that too.

Another year of Big Money and conference re-alignment ruining college football is upon us.

Being a month late, I apparently missed a whole lot of a drama with the game's launch. From what I've read, the Dynasty mode nerfed experience gain for players and coaches in order to sell XP boost micro-transactions. Without those micro-transaction XP boosts, users report that it would take 150 seasons of undefeated national championship runs to get a custom coach up to max level. (The game only supports 50 years of Dynasty Mode)

Things were so bad that apparently content creators and influencers (even the Ultimate Team ones!) were in active rebellion and recommending boycotts. EA back-tracked ... partially. The XP boost micro-transactions were removed, and the names of the Coach XP sliders were renamed in order to obfuscate whether a "fast" option is included or not. So maybe XP gain is back to normal, or maybe it's still slower than in past years. I don't know. Worse yet, EA still kept a paywall for certain coach skill trees.

Even influencers (such as Bordeaux) were quick to call out EA for its brazen attempts at pay-to-win monetization.

It actually teaches the game this time?

Upon finally receiving a copy of the game, I jumped into a quick exhibition match with last year's national champs expecting to feel right at home and breeze to an easy victory, and to start my reviewing process with the impression that the game hadn't changed much. I did breeze to an easy victory, but that had more to do with playing as the reigning national champs instead of anything I was doing. Instead, I actually felt surprisingly out-of-place. A lot of simple things from years past were different. For example, the commands for shifting defensive linemen and linebackers weren't mapped to the controls I expected, and I generally had no idea what any of the defensive pre-play controls did, because so many of them were moved, combined, or had unfamiliar commands in their menus. The buttons to view wear & tear weren't where they used to be, even though a quick trip to the setting menu confirmed that wear & tear is still in the game. And so forth.

So the next time I played, I went to the Training menu, expecting to be disappointed by a measly list of un-helpful mini-games that would force me to go to the internet to figure out where all the familiar commands had been moved to, and what new commands might be present. What I found instead was an exhaustive suite of tutorials, including an entire menu dedicated specifically to mechanics and features that were new this year, or significantly changed from previous years. On top of that, the tutorials showed subtle, but significant design improvements over the Madden counterparts that I had been familiar with for years.

There is [finally] an entire tutorial menu dedicated to new and modified features.

In general, these Skill Trainer tutorials lacked good feedback for what you might be doing wrong, if you are failing to execute the commands being tutorialized. In fact, when I got to the tutorial for the new timing-based catching mechanic, I was kind of stone-walled. There was no on-screen indicator, dial, or gauge of any kind telling me what to press or how long to press it. My receiver kept catching passes, but I wasn't given credit for executing the timing catches, and the game wasn't giving me any feedback on what (if anything) I was doing wrong. So I hopped on the internet and searched for "College Football 27 perfect catch tutorial not working", and immediately found a reddit post explaining that, by importing last year's settings, the timing-catch mechanic is disabled by default. That's right, the game's most significant and heavily-advertised new feature was disabled by default! I had to quit the Skill Trainer and turn on the timing-catch setting. Then, suddenly, the tutorial started working, and the rest of the Skill Trainer drills were mostly smooth-sailing and were highly informative.

[More]

Chicago Bears alt logo

CBS Sports columnist Pete Prisco has given the Chicago Bears a solid "A" in his 2018 Draft Grades. He's not the only one. The internet is abuzz with analysts praising the Bears' draft this year. Bears fans, on the other hand, seem less enthusiastic.

Maybe us jaded fans are just bitter from years of disappointment and bad decision-making at the highest levels of the Bears organization. Perhaps the analysts are just impressed that the Bears didn't metaphorically trip over their own feet on the way to the podium the way that they did last year with the dumbfounding decision to trade up one spot to draft Mitch Trubisky (a player that the team ahead of them, the 49ers, wasn't even planning on drafting), instead of taking the elite pass rusher that everyone thought they were trading up to get (and which the 49ers did take with that next pick). Was it the right move? Time will tell.

Well the Bears didn't impress anybody by picking up that desperately-needed pass rusher this year either. They had a chance in the second round to take Harold Landry, but instead took center James Daniels. Landry has had some injury issues in his college career, and consistently drafting injury-prone players has been one of Chicago's key failures in recent memory. Maybe Kevin White will finally play a full season this year? I'll settle for half a season.

The Bears drafted linebacker Roquan Smith from Georgia Tech 8th overall.

Top needs addressed and ignored

Despite not addressing their most pressing concern, the consensus among analysts seems to be that general manager Ryan Pace and newly-hired head coach Matt Nagy had one of the best drafts in the league (and one of the best drafts for the Bears in a long time). They picked up an inside linebacker, Roquon Smith, in the first round. He is expected to start immediately next to Danny Trevathan in Nagy's 3-4 defense, and should hopefully give former Georgia teammate Leonard Floyd more room to get pressure from the outside. The big question is: can Floyd or Trevathan stay healthy? Hopefully, Smith doesn't end up being the only linebacker left by the time December rolls around...

[More]
Grid Clock Widget
12      60
11      55
10      50
09      45
08      40
07      35
06      30
05      25
04      20
03      15
02      10
01      05
Grid Clock provided by trowaSoft.

A gamer's thoughts

Welcome to Mega Bears Fan's blog, and thanks for visiting! This blog is mostly dedicated to game reviews, strategies, and analysis of my favorite games. I also talk about my other interests, like football, science and technology, movies, and so on. Feel free to read more about the blog.

Check out my YouTube content at YouTube.com/MegaBearsFan.

Follow me on Twitter at: twitter.com/MegaBearsFan

Patreon

If you enjoy my content, please consider Supporting me on Patreon:
Patreon.com/MegaBearsFan

FTC guidelines require me to disclose that as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made by clicking on Amazon product links on this site. All Amazon Associate links are for products relevant to the given blog post, and are usually posted because I recommend the product.

Without Gravity

And check out my colleague, David Pax's novel Without Gravity on his website!

Featured Post

Exploring strange new ludic genres of Star Trek (on Patreon)Exploring strange new ludic genres of Star Trek (on Patreon)09/08/2025 2 years ago, after playing both Star Trek: Resurgence and Star Trek: Infinite, I started thinking about how the ludic genres of "point-and-click"-style adventure games and grand strategy games are both very good ludic genres for the Star Trek IP. I had originally planned on creating a short, 20-30 minute video talking about...

Random Post

Virginia straddles the line between movie and gameVirginia straddles the line between movie and game04/07/2021 I spent a large chunk of my gaming time since last August playing football video games. With the season over, I wanted to spend a couple months playing other games before diving back into to football critique videos with the next installment of my "How Madden Fails To Simulate Football" series. I also recently played Outer Wilds,...

Month List

Recent Comments

Comment RSS