submit to reddit
Pin it

It's a debate that's been going on for a decade: Is Tom Brady better than Peyton Manning?

Peyton Manning Tom Brady

Tom Brady has more championships, so the conventional wisdom would say that yes, Brady is superior.

But I think this week's season opener proves otherwise.

This Sunday marked the first time since 1997 that Peyton Manning was not the Indianapolis Colts' starting quarterback.

Championships aren't the only measure of quality for an NFL quarterback. Remember, Dan Marino never won a Super Bowl. He's easily the best player in Super Bowl era of NFL history to have never won a Super Bowl, and he's one of - if not the - best quarterbacks in history. And Manning does in fact have a ring! He won it against my Bears in 2006. But if somebody was going to beat the Bears in the Super Bowl, I'm glad it was Manning. The guy deserves it!

So how else can we compare them?

When in a leadership role like quarterback, I think one of the biggest criteria for the quality of that player is to compare how the team performs with him against how the team performs without him.

We already know that the Patriots are capable of performing well without Tom Brady. In 2008, Brady was injured and replaced by Matt Cassel in week 2. It was Cassel's first start in a football game since high school! Brady had suffered a serious knee injury, and so Cassel was the Patriots' starting quarterback for the remainder of the 2008 season. The team won 11 games, but did not make the playoffs due to Miami and Baltimore holding playoff-qualifying tie-breakers over them.

So it's easy to see that the Patriots are a well-oiled machine that are set up to win regardless of personnel. This has been proven time and time again as they have lost many major players to injury over the past decade, only to have the replacement perform admirably and for the team to be successful.

But we never got a chance to see how the Colts could perform without Manning.

Kerry Collins debut with the Colts is not pretty

Until now.

And it wasn't pretty.

Now, it might be a bit early to rule the Colts out for the season. They might still win some games, and Peyton Manning might be back for the last month of the season. So if the Colts can eke out 6 wins or so, and get Manning back in time for the last 4 or 5 games of the season, they might make the playoffs.

But that's unlikely.

And keep in mind that one of the Texans star players (last year's NFL rushing leader, Arian Foster) was sidelined in this game with an injury too!

When it all comes down to it, Tom Brady inherited a successful team. The Patriots were a playoff team in the mid-to-late 1990's, and Brady took over the team when they were coming off their only losing season since being beaten by the Packers in the 1996 season's Super Bowl five years prior.

Peyton Manning, however, inherited a 3-13 team that saw only three winning seasons in the decade before he got there.

With Tom Brady, the Patriots are an offensive juggernaut. Without him, they're still a competitive, winning team.

With Peyton Manning, the Colts have been a perrenial playoff team. Without him, they weren't even able to compete!

It's also very sad to know that Manning will not be unseating Brett Favre as the NFL's "Iron Man". Too bad...

Cam Newton breaks Manning's rookie record

Worth noting: On the first week in which Peyton Manning did not play since he was drafted, Carolina Panther quarterback Cam Newton broke Manning's record of throwing for the most yardage in a rookie debut in a losing game. Oh the little ironies of life.

Tags:, , , , ,

Contribute Comment


We'll incarnate your avatar from the services below.
PlayStation Network Steam Xbox LIVE Facebook MySpace Pinterest Twitter YouTube deviantART LiveJournal

  • Comment
  • Preview

Grid Clock Widget
12      60
11      55
10      50
09      45
08      40
07      35
06      30
05      25
04      20
03      15
02      10
01      05
Grid Clock provided by trowaSoft.

A gamer's thoughts

Welcome to Mega Bears Fan's blog, and thanks for visiting! This blog is mostly dedicated to game reviews, strategies, and analysis of my favorite games. I also talk about my other interests, like football, science and technology, movies, and so on. Feel free to read more about the blog.

Check out my YouTube content at

Follow me on Twitter at:


If you enjoy my content, please consider Supporting me on Patreon:

FTC guidelines require me to disclose that as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made by clicking on Amazon product links on this site. All Amazon Associate links are for products relevant to the given blog post, and are usually posted because I recommend the product.

Without Gravity

And check out my colleague, David Pax's novel Without Gravity on his website!

Featured Post

The Humanity of NCAA Football's In-Season RecruitingThe Humanity of NCAA Football's In-Season Recruiting08/01/2022 If you're a fan of college football video games, then I'm sure you're excited by the news from early 2021 that EA will be reviving its college football series. They will be doing so without the NCAA license, and under the new title, EA Sports College Football. I guess Bill Walsh wasn't available for licensing either? Expectations...

Random Post

I actually like playing the preseason in MaddenI actually like playing the preseason in Madden10/07/2019 If you've already read my review of Madden 20 on my personal blog, then you know that I consider this year's release to be a massive disappointment. In fact, the last Madden entry that I actually liked was probably Madden 17. Despite my misgivings about this year's game, I do want to start off by talking about something in recent...

Month List

Recent Comments

Comment RSS