Share
submit to reddit
Pin it

This review was originally published 06/29/2010 on Game Observer (now defunct as of 05/13/2014). It has been republished here for archival purposes.

Red Dead Redemption

The marriage of Wild-West theme with open-world gameplay is a great idea, but Red Dead falls just short of "genius."

In a Nutshell

  • Graphics: 86
    An incredibly life-like and detailed environment is only held back by noticeable texture and shadow popping and some occasionally very poorly detailed NPC characters.
  • Gameplay: 65
    Gunplay is great fun when you’re on foot, and exploration is satisfying, but some major control issues (mostly with the camera) during horseback combat and a frequent overdose of pursuing enemies and animals provide more frustration than fun in some parts.
  • Production: 92
    Typical of Rockstar, the game is huge and loaded with content in both Single and multiplayer, although a lot of it is recycled. The story is a well-written (somewhat Kafka-esque) take on the conflict between individual rights and the federal government that is as old as the country itself.
  • Sound: 98
    The world is full of ambient sound from the blowing breeze, to coyotes and wolves howling in the distance, to the approaching sound of a gun shoot-out. Characters are well-voiced and dialogue mostly sounds natural. The barely-there soundtrack fits perfectly with the look and feel of the game.
  • Value: 79
    The single-player story alone will take many hours to complete, but the addition of numerous multiplayer modes and the ability to free-roam with online posses will add even further enjoyment to the game. But the repetitive nature of much of the side content might get very old very fast for some.
  • Overall Score: 84
Red Dead Redemption cover art

Developer: Rockstar San Deigo
Publisher: Rockstar Games
Distributer: Take-Two Interactive
Platforms: PS3, Xbox 360
ESRB rating: M
Genre: Open-word, Third-person shooter, Action/Adventure
Players: 1-4 local or 2-16 online multiplayer
Official site: www.rockstargames.com/reddeadredemption

I was very impressed with Grand Theft Auto IV. Before the game had come out, I worried that the formula would be stale, and that Rockstar would just throw so much content into the game that it would overwhelm the player (San Andreas was a ridiculously complex game, although not in a bad way). The successfulness of Grand Theft Auto IV had me very excited about Red Dead Redemption, even though I hated its predecessor Red Dead Revolver.

The release of this game also made me realize how strangely devoid the gaming world is of Westerns. I guess game developers just didn’t feel the genre would be very popular with the younger audience. But Red Dead Redemption just might change that. The marriage of a Western theme and an open-world sandbox style of gameplay is a combination that seems absolutely genius. Red Dead Redemption, however, does not quite reach the level of "genius."

The not-so-lonesome cowboy

Koopa the tortoise
How do you make a game about the wild west, and not include any tortoises or lizards? As my choice of pets may imply, I was very disappointed by the lack of cute, scaly critters.

The world that RockStar has created is well-conceived for the most part. It is very detailed and lifelike. The scenery is that of a desolate desert, but still does not get boring. Landscapes in the distance that look like old matte painting backdrops for movies actually end up being real places that you can visit and walk around in. The desert is also populated with all kinds of animals: coyotes, dogs, horses, skunks, birds, snakes, deer, cows, buffalo, and so on (but no turtles or lizards apparently). The day/night cycle also seems to fit perfectly with the pace of the game. The only time it gets awkward is when you play a mini-game like poker or horseshoes, and the day goes from high noon to dusk before your eyes. The musical score also fits appropriately with the game’s setting. The animations of characters and dialogue help to add a degree of immersion that can suck you into the game’s world.

However, this world is not perfect. It seems way too dense. Every few steps my character seems to be getting molested by wolves or cougars or bandits robbing caravans. It takes a lot of the atmosphere out of the game, as there is no sense of "desolation" that you would expect to see from the likes of a Clint Eastwood movie. The mission structure also takes a lot out of the game. Just like GTA, you simply go to a location on the map to start a mission. Even ambient "Stranger" tasks are marked on the map even if your character has no reason to know where that "stranger" is.

Some towns have saloons and even sell newspapers, and it would have been very cool if missions could be triggered by overhearing gossip in the saloons or reading articles in the newspaper. But sadly, all the saloon patrons and newspapers only talk about things you’ve already done. It’s an unfortunate oversight by the designers, but not a game-breaking flaw by any stretch of the imagination. The world also suffers from moderate-to-frequent texture and shading pop-up on trees, buildings, and terrain features. Again, it’s not a game-breaker, just a minor irritant if you’re looking closely enough to notice it.

Red Dead Redemption - landscape Shadow of the Colossus - landscape

Don't let Red Dead's expansive environment and minimalist soundtrack fool you into thinking that it will have the almost-depressingly-desolate brilliance of Shadow of the Colossus. There's a lot more than just birds and lizards in New Austin, and they'll pop out of the grass to eat you alive sooner than you can spit.

Just be glad you’ll never duel on horseback

Gameplay is also a mixed affair. It gets very close to being great, but some control issues really drag down the experience. On foot, gunplay is incredibly fun. The targeting system might be a bit simplistic for some, as your crosshair will automatically snap to any enemy that you have centered in the camera’s field of vision. You can then move the crosshair to fine tune the shot and go try to disarm an enemy by shooting his arm, or go for the instant-kill headshot. It all works great. And if you think it’s too simple, you can switch the targeting mode to "Expert" where you have to do all the targeting yourself.

The only major complaint I have with on-foot gunplay is that sometimes the snap-to-cover feature doesn’t do quite what I want it to do, and sometimes when I’m trying to reposition my character around a boulder to make a shot, the character will go all the way around the boulder (because its round and doesn’t have a defined "edge"), and of course, he’ll be exposed and get shot at. There are other minor nuisances, like the triggering "Dead Eye" being the same button as the look-behind button (Dead Eye is triggered if you have a weapon drawn, otherwise, tapping R3 turns the camera backwards). And the weapon wheel is sometimes a pain.

Horseback riding is a bit more of a problem. The game uses a control scheme similar, but not quite the same, as Shadow of the Colossus, but after playing Shadow’s very believable and fun horseback riding, I don’t know if I can ever play any other game with horseback riding in it. The horses in Red Dead behave OK, but not great. You speed them up by tapping X and then hold X to maintain a speed. If you are following another character, you can hold X to automatically match their speed, which is a very nice feature. But holding X also leads to a problem when riding. Camera control is still handled by the right stick. And you are still going to have to deal with bad guys when on horseback, which means you are going to have to find a way to continue holding X while also moving the right analog stick to aim your weapon.

Red Dead Redemption - horseback combat
Fighting on horseback is necessarily frustrating due to poor camera controls and horse navigation.
It's especially problematic when being chased by bad guys, since your thumb will have to alternate between tapping X to speed up and turning the stick to rotate the camera backwards to look at the badguys, or you'll have to do some finger-gymnastics.

The game tries to make this easier by having the horse maintain speed for a few seconds after releasing X, giving you some time to move the stick. But the fast-paced nature of horseback combat means you’ll usually need more time to line up a shot than it will take for the horse to start slowing down, giving the bad guys a chance to catch up to you and surround you. It doesn’t sound like much of a problem, but it crops up frequently enough that it REALLY drags down gameplay. The horseback controls just aren’t comfortable. It comes very close to being a game-breaking problem.

I also didn’t particularly care for the dueling mechanic. It’s not that the mechanic itself is flawed, it’s just that the game gives you a tutorial the first time you do it (which is fine), but then I went several game sessions (and hours of time playing the game) before being challenged to another duel. As such, I had completely forgotten how dueling was supposed to work, and after the first time, the game stopped showing the tutorial tips. The dueling controls also aren’t in the instruction manual. So I ended up getting killed in numerous duels before I figured out the controls again. It wouldn’t have been so irritating if not for the fact that all the simple mini-games like Poker and Blackjack have all the pop-up tutorial tips reappear every time you play it. But for the one gameplay mechanic that I actually needed a recurring tutorial for, I didn’t get one…

Kafka would be proud

Like Grand Theft Auto, Red Dead Redemption is a very heavily narrative-driven title. And like so many of its other features, the story gets very close to being great, but still falls short due to minor problems. The plot is engrossing, the characters are interesting and compelling, and it deals with a lot of issues that are fundamental to the identity of the United States. The major theme of the game is the issue of individual rights versus the power of the federal government. It is an issue that goes back to this country’s inception. It’s an issue that divided America in two and triggered the Civil War. It is an issue that is still unresolved even to this day. It’s a big topic to handle, and the game deals with it very well.

Franz Kafka's 'The Castle'
Red Dead's plot feels very much like Kafka's novels: the protagonist is told by ominous government agencies to do some task and get dragged around in circles by bureaucracy and secondary characters that are all experts at deferring promises.

The only major issue I had with the story is that the game is very Kafka-esque. The main character is sent to this place by individuals we don’t know to kill somebody, gets shot in the meantime, and spends the next few weeks doing menial tasks for other people in the hopes that SOMEBODY will return the favor and help him get to the guy he’s after. But they keep dancing around in circles, and it just seems like nothing is getting done, and you’re not making any progress with your quest. It can be very frustrating to put whole nights of time into a game and not feel like the game’s narrative is going anywhere. I like Kafka (his short stories were better than his novels -- but I digress), and I understand how this particular style of story-telling fits well with the aforementioned themes of federal government influence, but this particular style of story-telling doesn’t really fit well with the setting. It makes for a very different kind of Western than most people will probably be used to. John Marston is definitely no Clint Eastwood or John Wayne.

Summary

Overall, Red Dead Redemption is still a fine game. If you like games with strong narratives, you’ll probably be more than willing to put up with the few gameplay hiccups that exist, and shoot-outs will reward you with fun, fast action. Unless it’s a horseback gunfight.

Other Game Reviews I've Published

Alan WakeAlan WakeAlien: IsolationAlien: Isolation
Amnesia: a Machine for PigsAmnesia: a Machine for PigsAmnesia: the Dark DescentAmnesia: the Dark Descent
Among the SleepAmong the SleepAssassin's Creed IIIAssassin's Creed III
Assassin's Creed IV: Black FlagAssassin's Creed IV: Black FlagBack to the Future Episode OneBack to the Future Episode One
Backbreaker FootballBackbreaker FootballBanishedBanished
Batman: Arkham CityBatman: Arkham CityBattlefield 1Battlefield 1
BloodborneBloodborneBloodborne: the Old HuntersBloodborne: the Old Hunters
CatherineCatherineCities SkylinesCities Skylines
Cities Skylines: After DarkCities Skylines: After DarkCities Skylines: Mass TransitCities Skylines: Mass Transit
Cities Skylines: Natural DisastersCities Skylines: Natural DisastersCities Skylines: SnowfallCities Skylines: Snowfall
Cities: Skylines: Match Day & ver. 1.4Cities: Skylines: Match Day & ver. 1.4CitiesXL & Cities XXLCitiesXL & Cities XXL
Dark SoulsDark SoulsDark Souls Artorias of the Abyss DLCDark Souls Artorias of the Abyss DLC
Dark Souls IIDark Souls IIDark Souls II: Scholar of the First SinDark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin
Dark Souls IIIDark Souls IIIDark Souls III: Ashes of AriandelDark Souls III: Ashes of Ariandel
Dark Souls III: the Ringed CityDark Souls III: the Ringed CityDead Space 2Dead Space 2
Demon's SoulsDemon's SoulsDmC (Devil May Cry)DmC (Devil May Cry)
DreadOutDreadOutF.T.L. (Faster Than Light)F.T.L. (Faster Than Light)
Fallout 4Fallout 4Fallout ShelterFallout Shelter
Far Cry PrimalFar Cry PrimalFinal Fantasy XIIIFinal Fantasy XIII
Final Fantasy XVFinal Fantasy XVFive Nights at Freddy'sFive Nights at Freddy's
Game of Thrones (Telltale series 1-2)Game of Thrones (Telltale series 1-2)God of War IIIGod of War III
Gone HomeGone HomeGrand Theft Auto VGrand Theft Auto V
L.A. NoireL.A. NoireLifeless PlanetLifeless Planet
Lollipop ChainsawLollipop ChainsawMad MaxMad Max
Madden NFL 11Madden NFL 11Madden NFL 12Madden NFL 12
Madden NFL 13Madden NFL 13Madden NFL 15Madden NFL 15
Madden NFL 16Madden NFL 16Madden NFL 17Madden NFL 17
Mars Rover LandingMars Rover LandingMaster of Orion: Conquer the StarsMaster of Orion: Conquer the Stars
Metal Gear Solid V: the Phantom PainMetal Gear Solid V: the Phantom PainMiasmataMiasmata
Middle-Earth: Shadow of MordorMiddle-Earth: Shadow of MordorNCAA Football 11NCAA Football 11
NCAA Football 12NCAA Football 12NCAA Football 13NCAA Football 13
NiohNiohNo Man's SkyNo Man's Sky
Papers, PleasePapers, PleasePortal 2Portal 2
Red Dead RedemptionRed Dead RedemptionResident Evil 7: BiohazardResident Evil 7: Biohazard
Resident Evil RemasteredResident Evil RemasteredRock Band 3Rock Band 3
Room 404Room 404Sid Meier's Civilization VSid Meier's Civilization V
Sid Meier's Civilization V: Brave New WorldSid Meier's Civilization V: Brave New WorldSid Meier's Civilization V: Gods & KingsSid Meier's Civilization V: Gods & Kings
Sid Meier's Civilization VISid Meier's Civilization VISid Meier's Civilization: Beyond EarthSid Meier's Civilization: Beyond Earth
Sid Meier's Civilization: Beyond Earth Rising TideSid Meier's Civilization: Beyond Earth Rising TideSilent Hill 4: the RoomSilent Hill 4: the Room
Silent Hill HD CollectionSilent Hill HD CollectionSilent Hill: Shattered MemoriesSilent Hill: Shattered Memories
Sillent Hill DownpourSillent Hill DownpourSimCity (2013)SimCity (2013)
SimCity BuilditSimCity BuilditSomaSoma
Spider-Man: Edge of TimeSpider-Man: Edge of TimeSpider-Man: Shattered DimensionsSpider-Man: Shattered Dimensions
Star Trek TrexelsStar Trek TrexelsThe Amazing Spider-ManThe Amazing Spider-Man
The Amazing Spider-Man 2The Amazing Spider-Man 2The Elder Scrolls V: SkyrimThe Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim DLCThe Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim DLCThe Evil WithinThe Evil Within
The Last GuardianThe Last GuardianThe Last of UsThe Last of Us
The SaboteurThe SaboteurThe SwapperThe Swapper
The Witcher 3 expansionsThe Witcher 3 expansionsThe Witcher 3: Wild HuntThe Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
This War of MineThis War of MineThis War of Mine: the Little OnesThis War of Mine: the Little Ones
Tomb Raider (2013)Tomb Raider (2013)Total War: AttilaTotal War: Attila
Total War: Rome IITotal War: Rome IITotal War: Shogun 2Total War: Shogun 2
Total War: Shogun 2: Fall of the SamuraiTotal War: Shogun 2: Fall of the SamuraiTrineTrine
Tropico 5Tropico 5Uncharted 3: Drake's DeceptionUncharted 3: Drake's Deception
Until DawnUntil Dawn 

Contribute Comment

avatar


We'll incarnate your avatar from the services below.
PlayStation Network Steam Xbox LIVE Facebook MySpace Pinterest Twitter YouTube deviantART LiveJournal



biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview


Grid Clock Widget
12      60
11      55
10      50
09      45
08      40
07      35
06      30
05      25
04      20
03      15
02      10
01      05
Grid Clock provided by trowaSoft.

A gamer's life...

Welcome to Mega Bears Fan's blog, and thanks for visiting! This blog is mostly dedicated to game reviews, strategies, and analysis of my favorite games. I also talk about my other interests, like football, science and technology, movies, and so on. Feel free to read more about the blog.

Follow me on Twitter at: twitter.com/MegaBearsFan

Featured Post

Real-life Civ wonders and going Viking in a European vacationReal-life Civ wonders and going Viking in a European vacation07/12/2017 Last November, my girlfriend and I took a trip to Denmark and visited the Viking Ship Museum in Roskilde. That was a great trip, and the ship museum was pretty great, but there were a couple things that we wanted to do, but which we couldn't because the ship museum doesn't operate them in the winter. For one thing, the museum...

Month List

Random Post

Bloodborne Card Game expansion suggestionsBloodborne Card Game expansion suggestions04/22/2017 I've written quite a few wishlist and feature proposals for video games on this blog. But today I'm going to do something that I don't think I've done before: suggest ideas for a board game expansion. In this case, I'm going to outline some ideas for my own user-made expansion ("mod"?) for Bloodborne: the Card Game. An official...